finnup.

TFSA vs RRSP vs FHSA

Put the same after-tax dollars into each and see what's left once the tax is paid.

With these assumptions

The RRSP comes out ahead

You deduct at 30% and pay back at 20%. The RRSP keeps the difference.

TFSA

No deduction going in, no tax coming out.

$21,459.35

yours after tax

Put in
$5,000.00
Grows to
$21,459.35
Tax coming out
none

RRSP

Ahead

Deduction going in, taxed as income coming out.

$24,524.98

yours after tax

Put in
$7,142.86
Grows to
$30,656.22
Tax coming out
−$6,131.24

The one rule that decides it

The return and the number of years don't pick the winner. They grow both accounts by the same amount. Only two things matter: whether your tax rate is lower when you take the money out than when you put it in, and whether the RRSP refund actually gets invested. Try changing the years: the gap gets bigger or smaller, but the winner never changes.